Sunday, 1 September 2013

Chartered Accountancy (CA)

Course: Chartered Accountancy (CA)
Eligibility: Appearing for Class 12 exam
Council: Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI)
Minimum duration: 4-5 years
Exams: May, June, November and December
Fees: Rs. 45,000- 50,000
Websitewww.icai.org
Our advice: Be ready for a rigorous course. Take coaching only when necessary, since it is expensive
IF THE words “Chartered Accountant” conjure up an image of a bespectacled person rummaging through company balance sheets, then brace yourself for a professional who is fast becoming an indispensable asset to companies. The placement figures according to ICAI this year are proof enough.  

The first phase of placements at the institute’s five metro campuses (out of 15) in the first week of March saw 320 candidates being picked up by companies on Day 1. The big four consulting and accounting firms namely - E&Y, PWC, KPMG and Deloitte - hired students directly from training institutes in smaller cities such as Jaipur, Indore, Chandigarh and Ahmedabad, a move that was partly motivated by cost factors, too. The number of CAs on the rolls of ICAI, is currently a whopping 660,000 (up from 3.5 lakhs in 2008), showing that the course is much in demand, owing to its increasing relevance to the current business environment. 

Beyond accountancy
CAs, today, have definitely carved a niche of their own, as compared to those with an MBA. While an accountant does the manual job of preparing the data and keying it into the computer to prepare a financial statement, it is a CA who interprets the same. MBAs on the other hand are hired in sales and marketing to deal with clients wherein they utilise their communication skills, optimally. Abhinav Suri who has worked with the corporate banking division of ICICI Bank, Delhi, says “Companies rely on a CA’s opinion; he or she is seen as a key strategist when it comes to the company’s finances.”  

Image: Madhu Kapparath/ Outlook Group
Today, CAs are recognised as professionals with a robust knowledge of finance who have the ability to take decisions that can impact the future of the company.  This is even more relevant in a dynamic global environment with an increasing need to manage risk, given the fact that many companies struggled with the recession last year. “As opposed to finance professionals who take care of the financial requirements of the company, the CA looks for the future implications and cost involved in it,” says Sharad Maheshwari, a partner with a CA firm in Indore.

With finance being the backbone of any organisation, a CA with an in depth knowledge of costing, funding, financing, accounting, structuring and compliance and also an understanding of the taxation regime and accounting methods, is a key person to count upon. 
ICAI Placement (2010)
  • No of registered candidates: 2,931
  • Candidates offered jobs: 1,411
  • Candidates who accepted: 1170
Top hiring sectors
  • Banking
  • Financial Services
  • Information Technology – Software
  • Mining
  • Oil & Gas Refining
  • Chartered Accountancy Firms
  • Iron & Steel
  • Heavy Engineering
  • Engineering Procurement and Construction
Top recruiters
  • ICICI Bank
  • Genpact
  • Infosys Technologies Limited
  • SBI
  • Deloitte
  • Coal India Ltd
Remuneration
Company CTC (Rs in lakhs per annum)
Axis Bank                           10.82
ITC Limited                        10.61
BPCL                                   9.5
A rigorous course
Thought it involves self-study, the CA programme is intensive and clearing all three levels, needs persistence. Students can register after Class 10 but are eligible to give the Common Proficiency Test (CPT) only after they appear for their Class 12 exams.  This is followed by Intergrated Professional Certificate Course (IPCC) followed by the Final Course. Registration for CPT is open throughout the year and exams are conducted in June and December. However, exams for IPCC and Final are conduced in May and November.

With a need felt to equip the CA with better communication skills, all those who pass the Final exam now have to complete a 15-day course in general management and communication skills. The three-year articleship (on-the-job apprenticeship) after completing IPCC is what distinguishes a CA from an MBA or an accountant who might learn the subjects but may lack the hands-on experience and practical application of concepts for daily situations.

Although the course fees are reasonable, the cost is much more for  coaching classes in all subjects. The course is also reviewed periodically. In December 2008, the Accounting Technician Course was introduced to meet the huge demand for second  tier accounting professionals for large, small and medium enterprises.  Class 12 students can clear this exam and work for a year to be qualified as Accounting technicians.

The CA’s role gets meatier  No one can claim to understand company balance sheets better than a CA. He primarily ensures that the financial transactions of an organisation are maintained according to the law. He also tracks cost of management of the company and manages tax matters. All companies registered under the Companies Act, are required to get their accounts audited only by practicing Chartered Accountants, thus making them an integral part of the financial departments.  

While in a company he is responsible for preparing data, in practice he is the person who has to check the accuracy and authenticity of the data prepared by somebody else. “For a practicing CA, the responsibility involves audit and advisory. For example, if the CA is the Statutory Auditor of a company, then he or she is responsible for giving an opinion on the credibility, fairness of the accounts to the shareholders and other stake holders. On the other hand, if he is an Internal Auditor or consultant to the company, his or her primary responsibilities are to the management and are similar to that of a Finance Manager/Controller of the company,” says K Kalyansundaram, Founder and Partner, Kalyansundaram and Associates, a Chennai-based auditing and consulting firm.

Amarjit Chopra
President ICAI

Changes in regulations, listing, convergence with IFRS, Corporate Laws, have increased the demand across sectors
From generalist to specialist
The scope of the CA’s job is fast moving beyond the traditional role. They are assuming advisory roles conducting due diligence of companies involved during mergers and acquisition (M&A) deals. From being generalists, they are now specialising in  Service Tax, International Taxation, Transfer Pricing, Information Systems Audit, Fraud detection (insolvency, bankruptcy), Risk Management, ERP, US GAAP, IFRS, WTO representations, property-related matters, investment banking, transaction advisory to name a few.  

The fact that CAs have considerable knowledge can also prove to be a challenge! They are looked upon as trouble shooters and solution providers. “The biggest challenge is to meet the high expectations of employers who expect us to manage any kind of critical profile,” says Tamalika De, who works as a Senior Manager (Operations) with ICICI Securities, Mumbai. Her responsibilities include supervising and reviewing daily accounting  of various exchange related trades and setting new processes having financial impacts in place, a new area for CAs.

CAs also act as arbitrators who settle disputes and as executors under a will or trust in order to carry out the administration of an estate or settlements. They are also engaged in activities like markets research, budget planning, working capital management, inventory control, policy planning, securities consultancy, registrar of issues of securities etc. Software companies and KPOs also hire CAs as Finance Managers, Financial Controllers and Financial Advisors. They can also be placed in government sector in roles such as Director (finance), Chief Executive and Head of the Department of the accounts.

Aptitude for the job
  • Interest in finance and numbers
  • Attention to detail, focus and dedication
  • Good analysis/interpretation skills
Specialisations after completing CA
  • Diploma in Information System Audit (DISA)
  • Certified Information systems Auditor (CISA)
  • Diploma in Insurance and Risk Management (DIRM)
  • Chartered Financial Accountant (CFA)
  • Diploma in Tax Management (DITM)
  • Indian Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS)
  • Chartered Institute of Mgmt Accountants (CIMA)
A well-paid profession 
A fresh CA passout can earn a minimum salary of Rs. 30,000- 50,000 per month, depending on the company and the sector he is hired into, in sharp contrast to the meagre stipend (Rs. 1,000-5,000) earned during an articleship. The lucrative salaries offered by international audit and consulting majors such as PWC, Ernst & Young, KPMG and Deloitte, also attract many aspirants. 

“Salary offered depends on whether the candidate cleared CA in the first, second or third attempt or is a rankholder. Past educational qualifications and communication skills are also selection criteria for recruiters,” says Sunil Goel, Director, GlobalHunt India, an executive search firm.  

Most CAs register for placements organized by ICAI in March at campuses across the country. This year the average salary offered to freshers was 6.58 lakhs. One-third of the candidates accepted jobs in the banking sector, making it the topmost recruiter. 

Most CAs opt for jobs but some choose to practice either on their own or with smaller CA firms. “In a job you get good packages along with a brand name. With a practice, one has to struggle initially. However, it does offer good exposure and returns after some years,” echoes Parul Gupta, who works as a partner with a CA firm in Delhi.

Working for a smaller firm could fetch you between Rs. 25,000- 40,000 per month. Be prepared to battle it out if you plan to start your own practice from scratch. It may fetch you a salary ranging from Rs. 5,000 to 25,000 per month. The caveat though is not to be led by the pay package. Instead focus on the learning during your tenure in either a CA firm or a job of your choice. 
The future
ICAI is in the process of finalising accounting standards in convergence with IFRS (International Financial Reporting Standards) expected to be ready by June 2010. As a part of the move, all companies will be required to follow the IFRS converged Indian Accounting Standards from April 1, 2011. The institute has started a massive exercise to train its members in industry as well as in practice. “As the Indian economy prepares itself for a phase of explosive growth and becomes an aggressive player in foreign markets, it will be the Indian CAs who will lead from the front,” concludes Kalyansundaram.  
Main areas of work
SegmentResponsibilities
AccountingPrepare, analyse financial reports and documents of an organisation
AuditingCheck the accuracy of financial statements, ensure that the accounts presented are drawn on correct accounting principles
Cost AccountancyMaintain cost auditing records, compile cost information, install cost control and perform cost audits
Taxation
 
Dealing with direct taxes (income tax and wealth tax), assessment of taxes, filing returns and providing advice on indirect taxes
Investigation
 
Examination of specific aspects of businesses for interested parties on new issues of share capital, purchase, sale or financing of a business and for reconstruction
ConsultancyManagement accounting and internal audit, Corporate law advice, project planning and finance and systems design

CA placements at Nestle, ITC, HSBC, more

THE first phase of their placement programme was conducted in February in 11 smaller centres across the country. ie Ahmedabad, Bhuvaneswar, Baroda, Coimbatore, Ernakulam, Indore, Jaipur, Kanpur, Ludhiana, Nagpur, Pune. 

73 interview teams participated at these centres seeking over 500 chartered accountants as compared to 35 interview teams present last year. 1710 candidates were shortlisted through interviews and 528 candidates were offered jobs. Last year, 1406 candidates shortlisted and 279 candidates received job offers.

The highest salary package offered at smaller centres last year was Rs.7.4 lakhs. This year the highest salary was Rs.9.05 lakhs. Last year, in the bigger centres, the best job offer received by there candidates was for Rs. 21 lakhs per annum for international posting. For the domestic posting, the best offer received was for Rs. 15 lacs per annum.
 
 Placements in smaller townsCampus Programme Aug-Sep, 2010Campus Programme Feb-Mar, 2011*
Number of Interview Teams3573 
Number of candidates short listed14061710 
Number of Jobs Offered279535 
Highest salary package offered Rs.7.4 lacsRs.9.05 lacs


The second phase of the placement programme, which kicked off from March 15, 2011 and concludes on March 28, 2011 – is being conducted in six centres: Bangalore, Hyderabad, Kolkata, Mumbai, New Delhi and Chennai. Over 120 recruiting entities are expected to participate in this programme. On the first day of the programme organised in Delhi and Kolkata, ITC made a job offer with a salary of Rs 13.92 lakhs, to six candidates. ICICI Bank offered jobs to 100 candidates. Olam International made an offer for international postings to 3 candidates for 54-68 lakhs per annum.
 CA placements in 6 metrosCampus Programme Aug-Sep, 2010Campus Programme Feb-Mar, 2011*
Number of Interview Teams156222
Number of Jobs Offered13981806
Highest salary package offered
DomesticRs. 15 lacs per annumRs.13.92 lacs per annum
InternationalRs. 21 lacs per annumRs. 54 lacs-Rs. 68 lacs per annum


 









Banking Sector marked the majority presence at Delhi Centre. Jobs were offered by banks like ICICI, IDBI, Bank of Baroda, Oriental Bank of Commerce, Corporation Bank, Canara Bank. ICICI bank offered 100 jobs to the candidates.

Metro-wise break-up
Centre
Jobs Offered in Aug-Sep’10
Jobs Offered in Feb-March’11
New Delhi
274
384
Mumbai
441
423
Kolkata
122
131
Chennai
120
161
Bangalore
109
108
Hyderabad
53
55


 









MNCs such as Reckitt Benkciser, L&TGenpact, Nestle, Olam, Lanco Infratech, are also participating. Other prominent companies include TCS, Indian Oil Corporation, Capital IQ ,Vedanta Resources Plc, Reliance Industries Ltd, ITC, HSBC, Infosys and Nestle. At Hyderabad centre, the highest offer was made by Aditya Birla Group to three candidates for 22.45 lakhs per annum for a domestic posting. At Kolkata centre, the highest offer was made by ITC to two candidates for 13.70 lakhs per annum for a domestic posting.

The Institute organises placement programmes for the benefit of newly qualified chartered accountants, twice every year. These programmes provide an opportunity to employers to interact with newly qualified CAs and is a cost effective mode of recruiting newly qualified Chartered Accountants.

The Institute also organises Orientation Programme for Newly Qualified Chartered Accountants by providing them with last-minute technical inputs and soft skills to face the interview process with confidence. For the current year, Orientation Programmes have been conducted at 17 centres across India.

CFA Program

THE Indian financial sector has gone through a sea change in the past two decades thanks to economic liberalisation and globalisation. This has brought in a host of advanced services in the arena including money market operations, merchant banking, international banking, portfolio management, lease financing, mergers, acquisitions that were little heard of a few years back.

Though the recent slow down has tempered expectations, the need for professionals who understand these domains is still very high and would only grow as the economic conditions improve. Ashok Verma, working as a SAP FICOConsultant with JKT Consulting and a CFA level II candidate, says, 'CFA is the only course available which gives the holder 'upper hand' in financial management and analytical skills as compared to other courses.'

The charter is considered by employers worldwide as a differentiator when it comes to recruiting people in the core areas of corporate financeinvestment managementinternational finance andfinancial services. While earlier many MBA's were being recruited by the investment industry, given the specialized curriculum provided by the CFA, most companies involved in making or managing investments insist on having the CFA for senior positions.
The CFA Program 
It was instituted by the CFA Institute in USA, a global association of investment professionals with nearly 100,000 members. This includes 84,000 CFA charterholders worldwide as well as 136 affiliated professional societies in 57 countries and territories. For those pursuing the CFA Program in the US, a four-year Bachelor's degree is the minimum requirement. However, in India, the course is open to graduates (with three years of education) and even those in their final year can enrol. Contrary to perception, it's not only those with a commerce background who are jumping the bandwagon.

'Engineers, doctors, English Honours graduates and even life science graduates enrolled for the exam come to us for coaching. Most of the IT professionals want to work on the finance side of their company and hence find CFA an attractive option,' says Sushant Suri, Director and Lead Trainer atFinguru, a Delhi-based CFA coaching institute. Those with a finance background might have an edge over others while studying for the Level I exam that tests the basics of finance. But over time, the subjects can be mastered by people from different streams as well, adds Sushant.
Levels of study
CFA Program is a self-study course that tests your knowledge in different areas over three levels of exams. With a pass rate of 35-40 percent for Level I exam and 45-50 percent for Level II, it's not easy though. Shweta Chamria, a CFA level II candidate currently working with the RPG group in Kolkata says, 'The CFA is a very competitive exam. People who clear all the three levels are held in high regard by the industry.'

Level I is about learning investment applications.
Level II is about applying them.
Level III focuses on using different applications for defining investment strategy and performing portfolio management.
Program curriculum 
It is based on a Candidate Body of Knowledge (CBOK) that has a total of 10 topics grouped into four functional areas: Ethical and Professional Standards, Investment Tools, Asset Valuation, Portfolio Management & Wealth Planning. (see figure on next page). Passing these rigorous tests requires a comprehensive understanding of accounting, economics, and portfolio management, as well as successful demonstration of a high level of proficiency in the valuation and analysis of both equity and fixed-income securities.

Level I exams are conducted twice a year (in June and December).

Level IIand Level IIIare conducted annually, only in June.

 
 
Approximate fee structure (Rs.)
Level
Programme enrolment (Only for Level I)
Exam registration
I
20,000 - 25,000
35,000 - 45,000
II
NA
35,000 - 45,000
III
NA
35,000 - 45,000
Registration
It starts 11 months before exam. For instance, if you are planning to sit for the June 2011 exam, you can start registering yourself by July 2010. The earlier you register, the lesser the fees you have to pay (see table for fee structure):

Level I candidates must pay a one-time enrolment fee plus exam registration fee.
Level II and III candidates need pay only the exam registration fee.
All payments are done online.
Hall tickets are posted online in late April for the June exam and late October for the December exam. The results are declared online in the last week of July and January, for the Level I June and December exams, respectively. Results of Level II and III exams (conducted only in June) are declared in the second week of August every year.

Depending on how the students clear the exam and time their papers, they can finish all the three levels in a minimum span of 18 months (Eg: Level I- Dec 2009, Level 2 - June 2010, Level 3 -June 2011), provided all levels are cleared in one go. According to the CFA Institute, the average time taken by a student is four years.

Clearing the exams is just one of the requirements to become a CFA charterholder. A person also needs to have at least four years of professional investment experience, be a regular member of CFA Institute and commit to abiding by the Institute's Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct.
Where they can work 
Broadly speaking, CFA Charterholders study markets, trends and stocks, and analyse them to provide insightful opinions on buying or selling companies/stocks and even make investment decisions. Sameer Bakhru, Managing Partner, Pan Venture Consultants gives us more insight. 'Essentially they can work on the buy side or sell side, valuing, selling or creating investments for companies or investors,' he says.

Buy side refers to a group of people who buy into investments. They include Mutual Funds (such asFidelityFranklin Templeton), which buy into listed companies and Private Equity funds (such asChrys CapitalBaring) that buy into unlisted companies.

Sell side refers to companies that sell investments to other companies or individuals, or manage client accounts. These may typically be investment management companies or brokerage outfits (that sell stocks to investors) such as HDFC SecuritiesICICI Securities or India Bulls.

Core finance division/ treasury departments of MNCs also hire CFAs who would manage the company's existing cash assets via short and medium-term investments in the treasury. In the M&A division, he/she would evaluate acquisition/takeover targets, and manage them during the M&A process.

(click on table to understand CFA Program structure)

One could be working as an Analyst researching companies in a particular sector (say telecoms), valuing them and zeroing in on the target share price of the companies. An analyst's role revolves around valuation of the companies he targets - higher the expected share price viz. the current price, greater are the returns expected out of investing in that company, Bakhru adds.

Investment managers study listed companies (if they work in a mutual fund) or unlisted companies (if they work in a PE fund). They manage a certain sum of money on a regular basis and take buyand sell decisions in the stock market. Wealth managers/relationship managers guide investors on what investments to make and operate independently or work with large private banks such as Citibank or HSBC.

Conclusion
There are only about 400-500 CFA (USA) charterholders in India. The number looks set to rise with 5,500 students registered for the December Level I exam. The qualification is being increasingly sought for its credibility, specialisation and the global recognition that comes with it, though it is tough to attain it. With the global economic downturn receding, market sentiments picking up and the financial sector set to regain its momentum, the future surely looks bright for CFAs in India.

Dr Ashvin P Vibhakar Managing Director,
Asia Pacific Operations
CFA Institute
 
Q. How many Indian students apply for the CFA Program every year? Has it increased/ decreased over the past few years? 
A. In fiscal year 2009, India ranked 4th with the number of registrations for the CFA® exam rising to nearly 14,500 (including those who gave Level I exams in December and Level I,II and III students in June 2009). A record 5500 students are registered for the Level I CFA exam to be held in Mumbai on December 6, 2009. Despite the uncertainty for Indian candidates seeking the CFA designation over the last few years, the number of registrations from India has increased steadily. This growth shows how determined Indian candidates are to pursue the CFA charter.
Q. What are the CFA Institute's plans in India? A. Currently, the CFA Institute has 108 CFA Program Partners worldwide, with 25 in the APAC Region. Once the legal situation in India is resolved, we look forward to partnering with strong Indian finance programs. We have signed a MoU with the Securities and Exchange Board of India's National Institute of Securities Markets (NISM) in June 2009 to jointly organize financial and investment educational training programs and research in India. We have already held a journalist training, exam development training, and a workshop on derivatives. We also hope that, barring legal constraint, we can establish an office in India to support our candidates and members on the ground in the future.
Q. How do you see the role of the CFA evolving in today's dynamic world?A. While the skill and knowledge base of CFA charterholders, the investment tools and applications they use, may be evolving according to the changing market needs and new financial innovations, their primary role has not and will not change. It is essentially to act at all times in the best interest of investors, placing investors' interests before their firms', and before their own

For law students: New All India Bar Exam

LAW graduate Anant (name changed) completed his law degree at a reputed college in Goa in June 2012. But instead getting a full-time job, where he would be able to learn under a senior lawyer, he is marking time as an “intern” in Delhi. “I am unable to get the Certificate of Practice without passing the All India Bar Exam, and my work as an intern will not count in my experience of work,” he shares. This year, the All India Bar Exam (AIBE) will be held on November 25, 2012, and the time lag between finishing studies and giving AIBE, has made life uncertain for law graduates.

Purpose of exam 
Conducted by the Bar Council of India, the All India Bar Exam is an eligibility exam for any law graduate to be able to practise in law in India. According to the Bar Council of India, the exam is intended to “assess capabilities at a basic level and set a minimum standard for admission to the practise of law; it addresses a candidate’s analytical abilities and basic knowledge of law”. Upon successfully passing the Bar Examination, the candidate becomes entitled to a Certificate of Practice, which is issued by Bar Council of India within 30 days of the date of declaration of results. All students graduating from the academic year 2009-10 onwards need to clear AIBE in order to practise law in India.
’Pass or fail’ test
The first edition of AIBE was held on March 6, 2011, and it has been conducted three times to date. The Bar Council of India’s objective for conducting this exam is to examine a candidate’s capability to practise the profession of law in India. The Bar Council of India aims to conduct the test at least twice each year, and publish the syllabus at least three months prior to the scheduled date of examination. This is a pass or fail exam, with no ranks, percentile, percentages or marks being declared. Also, there’s no limit to the number of times you can appear for the test. And once you clear the test you will get the eligibility certificate to practise in courts. The minimum marks to be secured to become eligible to clear the exam is determined by BCI.

How to apply
Facing too many controversies regarding this exam, BCI is trying to make the application process easier. It has started an online application system for this exam and students can log on towww.allindiabarexamination.com and apply. The entire application process includes three steps: Step 1- Register yourself on the website and get the application number; Step 2- Download SBI chalan, fill it and deposit fee in nearest SBI branch; Step 3- Log in on the website, go to the application form, fill all information, and submit application.

Plight of students
In 2012, the exam which was supposed to be held in May or June, has been postponed to November, thus putting law graduates who passed out in June 2012, in a fix. BCI has stated administrative issues as the reason for this delay. Since the exam is to be conducted on a large scale BCI wanted to finalise an agency that will conduct the AIBE every year. The Council has now hired a Noida-based IT implementation and delivery company for help, because none of the tendering third party agencies to conduct the exam were finalised. Rainmaker, BCI’s previous AIBE contractor will not be conducting the exam this time round. “Though we got the permission from BCI in August to practise in courts for a period of six months without clearing the AIBE, even that is too late. Now, everything is uncertain,” shares a student from Government Law College, Mumbai. BCI had allowed students in August to practise in courts temporarily for six months.  
All India Bar Examination
What it is all about
As per the notified All India Bar Examination Rules 2010, no advocate enrolled under section 24 of the Advocates Act, 1961 shall be entitled to practise under Chapter IV of the Advocates Act, 1961, unless such advocate successfully passes the All India Bar Examination conducted by the Bar Council of India. The Bar Examination shall be mandatory for all law students graduating from the academic year 2009-2010 onwards and enrolled as advocates under Section 24 of the Advocates Act, 1961.

Exam format
  • AIBE is an open book test; reading material and notes are allowed, electronic devices like laptops and mobile phones are not allowed.
  • The test comprises 100 multiple-choice questions from syllabus prescribed by Bar Council of India for three-year and five-year LLB programmes in India
  • There are two categories of questions: One, subjects that may be considered ‘foundational’ in nature that form basis for large areas of law; two, subjects, which a new entrant to the legal profession must also have a basic understanding of.
  • Questions are divided into ‘knowledge-based’ and ‘reasoning’ questions
  • Duration of exam is three hours and 30 minutes
  • Emphasis is on assessing the advocate’s understanding of an area of law, rather than on the ability to memorise large texts or rules from different areas of law.
(Students can click here for more preparatory material students. )

Exam delay in 2012

June 22: BCI puts notification on its website stating that AIBE will be conducted in August. Between June 22 and 24, the words “to be held in August” were removed from notification
Aug 1: BCI says exam not likely to be conducted before October as three months of preparation for the conduct of the exam was required.
Aug 16: The Bar Council of India gives provisional nod to fresh pass-outs to practise without attaining the Right To Practise certificate, mandatory for fresh law graduates to appear in courts.
Sep 5: BCI notifies that date of exam is November 25

Objective of exam 
Some like Anand Prakash Mishra, Programme Associate, Jindal Global Law School, questions the need to introduce such a test in the first place. “Conducting this exam indicates that you have no faith in the degrees given by your own institutes. For law graduates from a good institution, clearing this exam is nothing,” he shares. However, Ravi Pande, Assistant Registrar, National Law Institute University, Bhopal has a different view. “The number of law graduates in the country is increasing rapidly every year and because of this the number of half-baked lawyers is also increasing. Some kind of filtering is required to bring quality in law field like other areas,” he adds. Biri Singh Sinsinwar, Advocate member, Bar Council of India feels that the exam is required to help more capable candidates get the best opportunities. “But I think the exam should be made mandatory for law graduates before their enrolment in the state bar councils,” he suggests.

Sudden fee hike 
In October 2012, the fees were increased from Rs. 1300 to Rs. 1900 (excluding SBI charges) for first timers. For those who have registered previously and are retaking the exam, the fee is Rs. 1,400 as compared to Rs. 900, earlier. “Since there’s no limit on number of attempts, many unsuccessful candidates will sit for the exam again and again, which provides BCI with an opportunity to earn more. Smells like a money-making racket,” says Anand.
Manan KumarMishra
Chairman, Bar Council of India 

“Fee hike due to inflation”

Q. What is the reason for delay in conducting the exam?
A. There were some administrative issues. The lease term of previous agency got over. So, process of hiring another agency took lots of time. This time we have hired ITES Horizon. It’s a Noida-based firm. This agency will conduct the exam and Bar Council of India will not interfere in any process.

Q. How would you ensure no delay in conducting this exam from next time?
A. Now, all the administrative issues are resolved, so no delay now on. In fact, from next year we are planning to conduct it thrice a year and this will be conducted every fourth, eighth and twelfth month. And we will make sure that the entire process of conducting  this exam should go very smooth each and every time.

Q. Many advocates feel standard of exam is very low. Your view?
A. If the standard was low, then more students would clear the exam. Right now it is 36%. Also, think it in this way, if any student has taken his law degree from a foreign institute or reputednational law institute, for him this could be the easier to crack. But what about others, who have not studied in good institutes? For them it could be tough to clear. So the standard is not low. And as this exam is being conducted on the direction of Supreme Court, so Supreme Court judges will monitor this exam.

Q. Why has Bar Council hiked fees?
A. The fee has been increased due to inflation and we will make sure that the increased fee will be used for the welfare of advocates.

 
 
 
 “The bar exam is essential nowadays. I believe it will filter lots of students and it should improve the quality.”

Navaniti Prasad SinghHon’ble Justice, Patna High Court.
 
 
 
 

Low standard
 
 
 
 “The All India Bar Exam is actually too easy! This is insulting for us. During our course we go through rigorous training. And when we acquire our degree, we are asked to write another exam of no standard.”

A law graduate from Goa
 
 
 
 
Some students and faculty question the credibility of the exam. “The All India Bar Exam is actually too easy! During our course we go through rigorous training. And when we acquire our degree, we are asked to write another exam of no standard,” says a law graduate from Goa. “The All India Bar Exam is an extraordinarily ordinary exam. It is more of an elimination process than a selection process,” says V Seshaiah Shastri, Professor and Additional Dean, Faculty of Law, National Law University, Jodhpur. “This exam definitely holds relevance. But to solve problems of the field, this exam is certainly not an answer in its current format,” he adds.

Another faculty member of a premier law institute feels that the Bar Council should redesign the examination as the current standard is very low. “The Council should ask itself about the basic requirement for law graduates to join the profession,” he shares.

The general view amongst practising advocates is that the examination is a good beginning to help filter professionals in the area of law. However, they doubt whether it will fulfil the purpose due to the current standard of the All India Bar Examination.  

Law studies: 3-year vs 5-year courses, colleges, more

THE journey of Indian law schools from “institutionalised mediocrity” (a term used by our Prime Minister at a major conference on legal education some years back) to becoming centres of excellence in professional higher education has been fast. In just a decade or so, law has emerged as a sought after career.

Universities, law school network
We have law schools, which are universities in themselves; like the 16 premier National Law Universities or State Law Universities set up by Governments of Tamil Nadu and Karnataka, each set up under a separate Act of State Legislature. We also have Departments or Faculties or Schools of Law in the Central, State, Deemed or Private Universities. Further, there are hundreds of aided and  unaided, government and private law colleges affiliated to these universities.

Increase in test-takers
Law entrance exams are becoming increasingly popular and competitive with the passing of each year. The number of applicants for Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) rose from 10,773 in 2008 to 25,769 in 2012. The number of applicants for the three-year LLB course by Delhi University’s (DU) Faculty of Law doubled from 6127 in 2008 to 11,384 students.
 

Two types of courses
Static since independence, the Indian legal education saw landmark developments after the establishment of National Law School of India University (NLSIU) Bangalore in 1986 and the introduction of five-year integrated LLB course after Class 12. The LLB course is now available in two formats for two different audiences - 5-year integrated LLB course for Class 12 pass-outs and a 3-year LLB course for graduates of any stream. The advantage is that those who miss the bus after Class 12 due to various reasons still have an opportunity to study law after graduation.


aspiring-lawyers
Photo: Rohit Gautam
ASPIRING LAWYER'S Students attend a class at  the Jindal Law School, Sonipat, which offers both the five-year and three-year LLB programmes for Class 12 pass-outs and graduates
3-year LLB vis-à-vis 5-year LLB
How good is a three-year LLB versus a 5-year integrated law programme? Every law faculty is asked this question by a large number of students. The answer is very simple. Both courses are equally good and they should not be compared in the first place simply because they serve to two different audiences. If a candidate is a Class 12 student or has already passed out, he should go for five-year law without giving any thought to the three-year course in future. There’s no doubt that both the three-year and five-year courses should co-exist in an equitable manner; this is in the best interest of legal education and profession.

Law school offerings
Some top law schools or faculties like Faculty of Law, DU and Faculty of Law, Banaras Hindu University (BHU) continue to only offer the three-year LLB course. However, some top law schools like Government Law College (GLC), Mumbai and ILS Law College, Pune have also started offering the five-year LLB course.

New crop of law schools
Most new generation law schools, that is, those set up in the 10-15 years including the National Law Universities (NLUs) have excluded the three-year LLB from their offerings, and have marched ahead only with 5-year LLB course. However, Jindal Global Law School, among new generation law schools, is an exception and offers both 5-year BA LLB and three-year LLB.
Major law entrance exams for admission to LLB courses
5-year Integrated LLB (after Class 12)
Entrance ExamParticipating law schoolsWebsite
CLAT14 National Law Schools/Universitieswww.clat.ac.in
AILET - NLU DelhiNational Law University, Delhiwww.nludelhi.ac.in
LSAT IndiaOver 40 Law Schools including Jindal Global Law School, Sonepatwww.pearsonvue.com/lsatindiawww.jgls.edu.in
SETSymbiosis Law Schools Pune & Noidawww.set-test.org
www.symlaw.ac.in
CET of GGS Indraprastha University, Delhi6 law schools including USL, LS and
Amity Law School, Delhi
www.ipu.ac.in
CUSAT CochinSchool of Legal Studies, Cochinwww.cusat.ac.in
Bharti Vidyapeeth PuneNew Law College, Punewww.bvuniversity.in
Christ UniversityChrist University’s School of Lawwww.christuniversity.in
Panjab Univ. ChandigarhUILS Panjab University Chandigarhwww.puchd.ac.in
AMU AligarhFaculty of Law, AMUwww.amu.ac.in
Jamia Milia, DelhiFaculty of Law, Jamia Milia Islamiawww.jmi.ac.in
LAWCET of
Andhra Pradesh
All law colleges in AP affiliated to state universitieswww.apsche.org
CEE - KeralaFour government Law colleges of Keralawww.cee-kerala.org

3-year LLB (after graduation)
University of Delhi (DU) LLB Entrance TestFaculty of Law- Law Centre I&II and
Campus Law Centre
www.du.ac.in
BHU – UET (Law)Law School, Faculty of Law Benaras
Hindu University
www.bhu.ac.in
LSAT-IndiaJindal Global Law School OP Jindal Global University, Sonipatwww.pearsonvue.com/lsatindia/
www.jgls.edu.in
Panjab UniversityDepartment of Law, PU Chandigarhwww.puchd.ac.in
LAWCET of Andhra PradeshAll law colleges in AP affiliated to
state universities
www.apsche.org
CEE – KeralaFour Govt. law colleges in Keralawww.cee-kerala.org
Kurukshetra UniversityDepartment of Law, KU Kurukshetrawww.kuk.ac.in
MD University, RohtakDepartment of Law, MDU Rohtakwww.mdurohtak.ac.in
IIT Kharagpur (Own Test & LSAT-India)Rajeev Gandhi School of Intellectual Property Law, IIT Kharagpur)www.iitkgp.ac.in


DISPENSING jUSTICE is the prime concern of law but is an ideal yet to be realised fully
Employment trends
The five-year LLB, particularly at the NLUs have placed their graduates in national and international law firms, corporate legal departments and consulting companies, in much better way. However, the judges, academicians and law officers in the government mostly come from three-year LLB courses offered at university law departments and faculties. Important in this context for a law aspirant is to aim for and secure admission to a top law school/faculty to get a wholesome legal education and learning experience. 

Admissions system
The admission process to law programmes is not uniform. We have law schools admitting students through All India entrance exams like CLAT for National Law Schools/Universities, LLB Entrance Tests for Delhi University, and law colleges admitting students on merit, that is, secured in qualifying examinations. However, a vast majority of the top law schools admit students through entrance exams only. CLAT for NLUs and LLB Entrance Test for DU could be considered to be the most important law entrance exams of the country for five-year and three-year LLB courses respectively (view table for listing of major law entrance exams in India).

Eligibility criteria
1. Five-year LLB entrance exams: A candidate should be below 20 years of age as on July 1 to be eligible for CLAT. At some top law schools like NLU Delhi; GGSIP University, Delhi (including Amity Law School) and Faculty of Law, Jamia Milia Islamia, Delhi, the upper age limit is 21 years whereas at AMU Law Faculty it is 22 years. Candidates from reserved category are given a relaxation of two years. Further any student who has passed Class 12 with 50% marks (less 5 % for reserved categories) or has appeared for the Class 12 is eligible to write CLAT and other law entrance exams.
 

 
 
 
 “The LLB course is now available in two formats - 5-year integrated LLB course for Class 12 passouts and a 3-year LLB course for graduates of any stream. Those who miss the bus after Class 12 still have an opportunity to study law after graduation. 
 
 
 

2. Three-year LLB entrance exams: There is no upper age-limit for admission. However a candidate must be at least 17 years of age on the date of application. A graduation degree with 45% marks (40% for reserved category) is the basic qualification required. Universities like DU and BHU require minimum 50% marks while universities like Kurukshetra, Rohtak, Meerut require  only 45% marks in graduation.

As per the recent directive by Bar Council of India, applicants who have passed 10+2 or has a graduation degree through distance learning or correspondence mode, will also be considered eligible for admission for the integrated five-year or three year LLB course. However, applicants who have obtained 10+2 or graduation or post-graduation through open universities system directly without having any basic qualifications for pursuing such studies are not eligible for admission in law courses. 

Read our advisory on how to crack Law Entrance Examinations in January 2013 issue. 

ISM Dhanbad upgradation to IIT, students waiting for more than 3 years

It has been three years when HRD government decided to include ISM Dhanbad in IITs, but students are still waiting for an IIT tag for their institute. Around 1500 institutes have threatened the government to go on indefinite strike from September 2.
Kalpesh Agarwal, one of the students leading the movement said, “A large number of students have left for New Delhi to mobilize support of the MPs. The government had promised to upgrade ISM to an IIT. Chandan Agarwal in Rajya Sabha and Inder Singh Namdhari in Lok Sabha had raised the issue and the government had given us verbal assurances.”
Students took out a protest march in Dhanbad late on Saturday to press for their demand. They will continue their protests in Dhanbad and Delhi simultaneously. A delegation of ISM students met P N Singh, a Lok Sabha MP from Dhanbad and submitted a memorandum seeking his support.

11 NIT students will be out from campus placement due to ragging

According to sources National institute of technology silchar is going to take punishment action against 15 students of V semester because of their involvement in ragging. 4 out of 15 accused students will be suspended, the rest would have to pay a fine of Rs 5,000 each and will be disqualified from appearing in campus selection tests.
In last week 50, 3rd semester students were ragged by their seniors. To set an example for others, NIT will suspend 4 students and others will be asked to leave NIT hostel and will not be qualified candidates in campus placement process.
This incident came to light only after the victims wrote to the joint secretary to the ministry of human resource development and technical director of all NITs, New Delhi, without informing this to the director of NIT, Silchar or other local authorities. This created a flutter in the institute and authority was swift in taking action against the accused.